I really though that this was going to be a really huge deal. So much was toted about both new browser versions that I was near foaming at the mouth for the releases. I am an avid Firefox user and promoter but please dont take my opinion as biased (even though it probably is). I installed both browsers and gave them a fair shake. But honestly, after testing both browsers, I must say, that I was disappointed.
Not by just one, but both browsers.
IE7 Review
Ill start with the obvious target for scorn and ridicule, IE7, as they are the biggest let down in this sham of a new browser war. It starts with the download. I had to hop through a few hoops to get it. Not many, but it was certainly too many to go through just to download a file. Then I realize the installer is just an installer and will download the rest of the browser. In short, another hoop.
Once it was downloaded, I hit install (finally), went through a few confirmations, and then it said I had to restart my system. (WTF? Its just a web browser). So fine, I restart my system and finish the IE install. By now, it is approx 15 minutes after going to the IE7 page.
So, all installed and ready to go, I click the icon. Then I have to configure it. Errrrgg. I click a few boxes just for fun (and to get on with using it) then get a warning saying I have to restart IE for my settings to take effect. Great. I restart IE and get, not my homepage (Google), but another warning saying that my configuration is complete! I know its complete because I hit the freaking save button! Anyway, finally I hit F6, go to Google and stop my time tracker.
Total install time: 23:18.
Some may say Wow, that was a decent install time. I say Thats 23 minutes of my life I would have rather spent poking venomous, ill tempered creatures with a stick. I’m a little sarcastic like that.
The pluses for IE7 are few so I will name them here. It is said that IE7 has the best security of any browser. Well it must because anything that complicated to configure must be secure. It also has tabbed browsing (finally) which is quite handy and would be more of a wow factor if they had added it 5 years ago when we asked for it. Other than that, the removed the tool bar and made it a flyout menu on the right which is a little cool once you get used to it.
The minuses are, well, greater than the pluses, but here are some of the highlights for the minuses:
- Still has shitty CSS validation (if not worse than previously)
- No option to set for links that have _blank targets to open in a new tab instead of a new window
- I hate the gold/yellow color on the icon
- Set up was too complicated for most normal people and impossible for those who arent computer savvy.
- Way too many confirmation boxes to go through. If I want to set something, then I set it. I meant to set it. And if I want to change it Ill do it later. Dont keep asking me if I’m sure. If I wasnt sure, I wouldnt have dont it in the first place!
In short, avoid this browser like the plague it is. IE 6 was at least as good (if not better) than IE7 so please, dont upgrade. For the websites you visits sake.
Firefox 2.0
After the debacle of installing IE7, I was hoping for a bit smoother ride form FF2.0. And I was not let down.
Went to the download page, clicked one button, and in less than 30 seconds had the executable on my desktop. A quick clickity later and it was installing (after pausing only momentarily to confirm the standard install stuff).
After that was done, it informed me that it was done and thanked me for using Firefox. Another clickity on the icon and a new screen appeared (and no, it wasnt the browser). It was the Mozilla plug-in checker and it was scanning my plug-ins for compatibility. After that, it checked for updates for the incompatible ones, found some and installed them, and informed me of what was not going to work in FF2.0 (sadly, my screen grabber extension and 2 of my themes were affected).
Once it restarted itself (it didnt bother to ask me or confirmation) it brought up my homepage (Google) just as it did before the install.
Total install time: 6:14.
Once it was installed I looked for the new features but they were not very obvious. There was no little paperclip character telling me what was new, and no floating arrow pointing to a new menu, and my homepage wasnt hijacked to tell me how awesome the new browser was. The new features and changes were explained on the homepage (most of them being under-the-hood fixes) and not really toted a lot.
In fact, after the 6 minutes of installing and 5 minutes of reading the changes documentation, I was cruising the web as if nothing were different. I think once of the greatest advantages to the new version of Firefox is how seamless the upgrade went and how invisible the changes are. You may notice a speed boost or some minor things, but other than that you will not notice anything. This is FF2.0s greatest achievement.
The drawbacks are also bundled with the greatness though. The lack of new hot features may turn off some people (maybe more than some people) as they would want something that is as earth shattering as IE7s tab feature (meh). This is sadly not going to happen. While FF2.0 is a major (and much wanted and needed) upgrade, it is not packed with all of the razzmatazz IE7s upgrade was. However, this was the only bad thing that I found with it.
Conclusion
I will make this as simple as I can for those who are now probably quite tired of listening to my ramblings in their brains.
Avoid IE7.
Get Firefox.
Period. Fin. End of story. Goodnight Nurse.
-Cheers